A Django site.
January 26, 2008
» SCM systems comparison: a better frontend

We’ve reorganized the information from the famous Better SCM: Comparison project, and presented it in a more useful way.

Announcing: Version control systems comparison 2.0.

You may compare any number of systems against each other. See for example:

TODO: add (at least) Git, PlasticSCM and Microsoft TFS information to the original Better SCM database and re-import it here. Stay tuned for updates.

January 13, 2008
» AccuRev streams vs branches

Damon Poole (CTO of AccuRev) wrote a teaser post in AccuRev blog about AccuRev streams: Damon Poole: “Streams vs Branches”.

This article links to a whitepaper: Damon Poole: “Stream-based architecture for SCM.

As far as I understood from the first reading, idea of streams is very straightforward and simple concept making “streams of development” a first-class object in AccuRev repository. Streams are very easily presented on UI level, making them easily understood for software developer and release manager. Branches, tags, and private workspaces could be superseded by various flavors of streams.

E.g. “Release 4.0″ is a stream. “Release 4.0.1″ is the child stream. Changes made in 4.0.1 could be “promoted” to 4.0. When we start the “5.0″ line of development, it automatically gets everything that was promoted to 4.0, either from older version or from bug-fix version (4.0.x).

I understand that streams could be enormously useful if they actually do the merging well. Technically this is handled easily by modern standards. Something like this could be done (and may be is already done) in many GUI clients for most open source version control systems.

Second part of the whitepaper is dedicated to AccuRev TimeSafe, which is the underlying repository format. I have to remark that the article only compares TimeSafe features with CVS and ClearCase repository features. Those are embarrasingly easy targets for criticism. Why are modern repository formats such as Subversion FSFS and Git not mentioned? Are they technically superior? ;)

Article on Timesafe: Damon B. Poole “The Timesafe Property - A Formal Statement of Immutability in CM”.

See also: DaveOnSCM: “Agile: Branches vs. Streams”.

October 10, 2007
» Karl Fogel, Ben Collins-Sussman, on distributed version control

Important opinions from Subversion developers:

Karl Fogel: “Subversion, decentralized version control, and the future”

Ben Collins-Sussman: “The Risks of Distributed Version Control”

October 6, 2007
» Mark Shuttleworth on renaming and merging

Mark Shuttleworth (of Thawte, Ubuntu, and Canonical fames) wrote four posts on rename tracking feature in version control systems, and its impact on merging as a social process.

Read at his blog:

Those posts caught a lot of attention back in June, but frankly it seems to me the issue is somewhat overrated (but nevertheless a recommended reading). Mark’s Canonical Ltd. supports the development of Bazaar. Bazaar has the discussed feature of merging with renames tracking. Git does not have it, but it has another argument in this discussion: huge merging traffic — Linux kernel development is all about merging, and the codebase is huge. So, I guess this feature is not that crucial: Linus is well-known by his uncompromising approach to tools.